Jorge Davy-Méndez
Frankenstein by Mary Shelley is broadly recognized as the first science fiction story, but it is also a story about class, belonging, and furtive desires. The book has been widely interpreted through a gay lens across media, largely because Mary Shelly and her husband Percy Shelley’s supposed gay relations and connection to Lord Byron provide a jumping off point for this type of analysis. Indeed, the development of, and desire for, strong male friendships dominate the book, both for Victor Frankenstein and the Creature as he undertakes his own journey [1]. However, scholars have noted that the homosocial bonds of friendship across the male leads falter, preventing them from fully developing as individuals, and possibly preventing them from passing through manhood [2].
I do believe that failure occurs, but not merely because the Creature’s attempts at friendship fail, but because the relationship between Victor and the creature fails to be consummated. Sex in the novel is never explicitly mentioned, but scholars such as Mair Rigby, drawing from Foucault, interpret the lack of sex in Frankenstein as the “privileged site of ‘truth '... The absence of sex from the text highlights its secrecy, bringing it even farther forward in the mind of the reader [3]. In this context, the male-male friendships the characters seek and value represent both emotional and sexual companionship. I believe that as it becomes impossible for the men in the story to be happy through their relationships with other men, they displace this yearning and focus their desires toward a female partner, viewing the female partner as a vessel for a more standard heteronormative life, in search for emotional stability. This response to ‘seek the closet’ with now-internalized homophobia fails to save them because Victor and the Creature take actions to prevent this for each other, which I will hope to show. I also want to emphasize that self-actualization through same- and even opposite- sex relations is harder for the Creature than Victor as, for the Creature, there is an added layer of “monstrous being” that further alienates him from those he desires, leading to further distress and rage. Indeed, once the Creature decides to pursue the creation of a female creature, he cannot desire any woman: he requires a Creature, like himself, in the female form. Through the Creature’s journey learning from, and engaging with the other characters in the book, he realizes he must subvert his desires. He suffers the full weight of normative intersectional pressures, even in his attempts to conform, because of the original sin of Victor’s abandonment.
The abandonment
The major catalyst for destruction in the book is Victor’s refusal to love and care for the Creature. He crafts this specimen only to leave him to fend for himself and suffer the ignorance and discrimination of the people he comes across. Before the Creature gains sentience, Victor admires him:
“His limbs were in proportion, and I had selected his features as beautiful. Beautiful! —Great God! His yellow skin scarcely covered the work of muscles and arteries beneath; his hair was of a lustrous black, and flowing…”
Victor creates a “beautiful” creature from inanimate parts, but immediately after doing so, he flees the scene, an act which could be seen as representing “homosexual panic.” This term comes from John Lauristen, who defines it as a “hysteria resulting from a clash between intense homosexual desire and social condemnation [4].”Unfortunately, this act condemns both Victor and his creation’s potential sexual partners.
Subverted desires and their effects
Victor creates something to satisfy his own desires, intellectual and physical, and on abandoning the Creature in a fit of sexual confusion, leaves him to forge his own difficult sexual and psychosocial path forward. The only man who could fully understand the Creature deserts him.
As the Creature matures, he interacts with the locals and understands he is feared. He finds a family he believes can act as his “protectors” and sees the patriarch, De Lacey, as a unique opportunity. He is blind, which the Creature believes will allow him to interact with the Creature free of bias. This friendship with De Lacey could act as a ‘bridge’ to broader society for the Creature.
However, here is another layer to the Creature’s search for companionship. We know the Creature himself is aware of differences in perceived “personhood,” but he is also aware of different races through Safie, a Turkish love interest of a member of the De Lacey family. In Gothic literature, monsters often represent “racial others” and threats [5], and in seeing Safie embraced, the Creature could have been comforted that the family could also accept him. The Creature determines that he cannot be denied the broader family’s companionship, what with De Lacey’s friendship, their history with Safie and other Turkish figures, and the fact he sees the family help the poor that arrive at their door (they “were never driven away”).
Ultimately the Creature’s reasoning fails. He enters their house and starts a conversation with a sympathetic De Lacey while the rest of the family is on a walk, but when they return, the Creature petrifies them. One of them batters the Creature, who pitifully grasps the old man’s knees.
The Creature is now bereft of companionship, and understands he can only have a connection with one of his same “being.” Having been rejected by men, and understanding from literature and the family he observed that heterosexual relationships are the norm, he resigns himself to heterosexual companionship. The internalized homophobia leads him to request from Victor “one as deformed and horrible as myself [that] would not deny herself to me. My companion must be of the same species, and have the same defects… You must create a female for me…”. In his ask, the Creature makes it very clear that he wants to “solve” for any possible reasons the female would reject him, in both class and nature, while forgetting that the new creature could enjoy her own agency. He does seem to ascribe this agency to female “humans,” whom he does not believe he could force to love him. Victor relents before ultimately deciding against it, destroying the Creature’s would-be female partner.
Denied a connection to Victor and a chance at a more normative heterosexual relationship with a female Creature of his own kind, the Creature murders Henry Clerval, Victor’s own male interest and friend.
Henry is Victor’s childhood friend in Geneva, and acts as a foil to Victor in many ways. Henry is focused on more ‘worldly’ matters such as politics, and the moral relations of things, whereas Victor, born “Genevese, [whose] family is one of the most distinguished of that republic”, enjoyed a “competent fortune” which allowed him the chance to “learn the hidden laws of nature.” Henry is whom Victor finds after fleeing the Creature on the night of the creation, seeing him outside of an inn, and grasping his hand, “[feeling] suddenly, and for the first time during many months, calm and serene joy.” Henry deeply cares for Victor as he nurses him back to physical and emotional health immediately after Victor flees the Creature. We see this was a meaningful relationship for Victor, who crafts this touching remembrance after Henry’s death:
“And where does he now exist? Is this gentle and lovely being lost forever? Has this mind, so replete with ideas, imaginations fanciful and magnificent, which formed a world, whose existence depended on the life of its creator; has this mind perished? Does it now only exist in my memory? No, it is not thus; your form so divinely wrought, and beaming with beauty, has decayed, but your spirit still visits and consoles your unhappy friend.”
The Creature murders Victor’s male interest and chance at self-actualization as a gay man since he was a twice-spurned lover: he was denied a connection to Victor and a chance at a more normative heterosexual relationship with a female Creature.
Victor, now also lacking his own male companionship, quickly moves to marry Elizabeth, the cousin he grew up with. The mood of the wedding day is morose, both because the Creature casts a heavy shadow over his life, and because Victor has promised to share “a secret” (ostensibly the creation of the Creature) with Elizabeth after their wedding.
The lingering “secret” upsets them both and, in the context of the broader story and the recent death of Henry, hints at the later phrase from Lord Alfred Douglas as the “love that dare not speak its name,” famously repeated by Oscar Wilde in the trial where he was prosecuted for homosexual behavior.
Victor never reveals his secret, as, after one last plea from Elizabeth after the wedding, “What is it that agitates you, my dear Victor? What is it you fear?” the Creature murders her. The Creature, emulating the trauma that Victor inflicted on him, now denies Victor his own chance to live a closeted heteronormative life.
A path towards love
The novel actually begins and ends with Captain Walton, a ship captain interested in “ascertaining the secret of the magnet” in the icy North, and who, in a series of letters to his sister, recounts his experiences and those of Victor and his Creature, while framing the theme of male friendship in conversing with the “attractive and amiable” Victor.
Victor dies in Captain Walton’s cabin, and then the Creature appears, lamenting his circumstances: “My heart was fashioned to be susceptible of love and sympathy; and when wrenched by misery to vice and hatred, it did not endure the violence of the change…” The Creature, believing that no one can love him after Victor’s death, self-immolates.
The Creature sought comfort and love in ones he believed he could trust, and was continually rebuffed. He suffered even more as an intersectional being, navigating cultures and expectations he attempted to understand and provide a logical basis for, ultimately failing to find solace in his search for acceptance and attempts to conform. This is, unfortunately, a common story as people come to terms with their sexuality and “come out” to experience non-strictly-heterosexual lives, and the novel asks the reader to reflect on how rejection and isolation breed discontent, and why listening to, and supporting, those in search of themselves is important.
Jorge lives in Durham with his husband, corgi, and various plants. Night School offers him the opportunity to understand and analyze novels he may have otherwise not read, from perspectives he hadn't considered, which he's deeply appreciative for.
References
Hale, Jessica. "Constructing Connectedness: Gender, Sexuality and Race in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein." Last modified 2001. https://bpb-us-w2.wpmucdn.com/wp.ovptl.uci.edu/dist/e/3/files/2023/09/2001_Jessica_Hale.pdf.
Mihailovic, Sophia. "Monstrously Alone: Abjection and Alienation in Frankenstein." Paper Shell Review (Spring 2019). https://english.umd.edu/research-innovation/journals/paper-shell-review/paper-shell-review-spring-2019/monstrously-alone.
Liggins, Emma. "Sex and Sexual Violence in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein." Inquiries Journal 9, no. 1 (2017). http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/articles/1553/sex-and-sexual-violence-in-mary-shelleys-frankenstein.
Smajic, Srdjan. "Monsters and the Moral Community: Mary Shelley's Frankenstein." The Gay & Lesbian Review Worldwide 27, no. 3 (2020). https://glreview.org/article/article-718/.
Spooner, Catherine. "Gothic and the Politics of Race." In The Cambridge Companion to the Modern Gothic, edited by Jerrold E. Hogle, 42-58. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014. https://cambridge.org/core/books/cambridge-companion-to-the-modern-gothic/gothic-and-the-politics-of-race/1C001566C0133D7BE70F2FD5C544AD08.